The AMF Enforcement Committee fined UK asset manager H2O AM LLP โฌ75 million and its executives Bruno Crastes (โฌ15 million, plus a 5-year ban) and Vincent Chailley (โฌ3 million) for breaches in managing French UCITS funds, including ineligible Tennor Group investments, liquidity risks, valuation failures, and non-compliance with investment ratios and counterparty limits. This matters as it underscores AMF's strict enforcement on UCITS eligibility, risk management, and prospectus adherence, with cross-border implications confirmed by the Conseil d'รtat's dismissal of appeals on 13 June 2025. It signals heightened scrutiny on illiquid, unrated assets and "buy & sell back" transactions for EU asset managers.
What Changed
This is an enforcement decision, not new rules, but it reinforces existing UCITS requirements under French Monetary and Financial Code and AMF regulations:
UCITS investments must exclude illiquid, unrated securities outside prospectus scopes; liquidity risks must be properly assessed to ensure redemption capabilities.
Debt holdings per issuer capped at 10%; counterparty exposure (e.g., 5% limit) must include all relevant transactions like buy & sell backs.
Reliable valuation information required; risks of unwinding transactions at market value must be evaluated.
These align with parallel FCA...
What You Need To Do
- Review portfolios
- Enhance due diligence
- Strengthen governance
- Depositary checks
- Training/remediation
Key Dates
30 December 2022 - AMF Enforcement Committee decision SAN-2023-01 imposing fines and sanctions.
7 August 2023 - Conseil d'รtat rejects preliminary constitutionality question.
13 June 2025 - Conseil d'รtat dismisses appeals (n. 471548, 471744), upholding sanctions and ordering โฌ3,000 costs to AMF.
June 2025 .
Compliance Impact
Urgency: High - Finalized enforcement (June 2025) with massive fines (โฌ93M total) and bans demonstrates AMF's willingness to pursue personal/executive liability for UCITS breaches, especially cross-border. Matters for firms with illiquid strategies, as it amplifies post-2020 liquidity crisis lessons (e.g., H2O fund gates), risking similar sanctions amid rising AMF actions on depositaries and managers.