CP26/40: Exempting performance fees from the workplace pensions charge cap
AI Analysis
The FCA has opened CP26/40 to consult on excluding specified performance-linked fees from the 0.75% annual charge cap applying to default funds in FCA-regulated contract-based workplace pensions. The proposed optional exemption is intended to facilitate investment in private equity, venture capital and private credit, but would be conditional on value-for-money, transparency, fair fee allocation and private-asset valuation safeguards; final rules are currently expected in summer 2027.
Key dates
- 2026-11-12
- FCA consultation CP26/40 opened and was first published.
- 2027-01-14 Deadline
- Deadline for responses to CP26/40.
- 2027-06-30
- The FCA currently expects final rules in summer 2027; no precise implementation date has been set.
Suggested considerations
- Compliance teams may wish to assess whether existing default-fund investment strategies, private-market mandates and performance-fee arrangements would qualify for the proposed exemption, while treating the current 0.75% cap as continuing to apply until final rules take effect.
- Firms considering responding may wish to submit comments to the FCA by 2027-01-14, including evidence on fee structures, valuation practices, member outcomes, operational costs and the practicality of the proposed information-sharing requirements.
- Pension providers may wish to map all charges in private-market investments, distinguishing performance-linked fees from fixed management, administration, transaction and other charges that would remain subject to the cap.
- Firms may wish to develop or review controls for documenting why a performance-fee structure is expected to create additional net value for savers, including comparisons with flat-fee alternatives and consideration of investment risks, costs and returns.
- Providers and fund managers may wish to evaluate whether investment agreements contain sufficiently precise provisions on hurdle rates, high-water marks, accrual and payment methodologies, realised or unrealised performance, fee allocation and information disclosure.
- Governance functions may wish to assess whether Independent Governance Committees and other oversight bodies will receive timely, sufficiently granular information to scrutinise performance fees, including information concerning underlying funds in fund-of-funds structures.
- Firms may wish to review member-allocation methodologies so that savers bearing performance fees are broadly aligned with savers receiving the corresponding investment benefit, particularly where private-asset performance and fee crystallisation occur over different periods.
- Providers may wish to assess private-asset valuation governance, including manager valuation policies, independent review, conflicts management, valuation frequency and escalation procedures, against the proposed requirement to establish reasonable grounds that appropriate valuation arrangements exist before investing.
What changed
The FCA is not yet changing the rules. It proposes to permit qualifying performance fees to be excluded from the 0.75% charge cap, broadly aligning contract-based schemes with trust-based schemes following the DWP’s 2023 exemption for certain performance fees. The exemption would apply only to fees calculated by reference to investment performance, with pre-agreed terms governing how fees are calculated and when they become payable; fixed management fees and other charges would remain within the cap. Proposed safeguards include pre-agreed information-sharing obligations, access for providers and Independent Governance Committees to fee and valuation information, scrutiny of private-asset valuation policies, fair allocation of fees between savers receiving the relevant investment benefit, a
Compliance impact
The proposal could materially expand eligible private-market investment options for FCA-regulated workplace pension defaults, but it does not remove the need to demonstrate value for money or maintain charge-cap controls for non-exempt charges. The FCA’s proposed safeguards create potentially significant governance, disclosure, valuation, recordkeeping and oversight requirements, and independent m
Who is affected
Related regulations
References
AI-generated analysis. May contain errors or omissions — verify with the original FCA source before acting. Full disclaimer.
What the FCA said
We're consulting on proposals to exempt certain performance fees from the charge cap for workplace default pension schemes operated by FCA-regulated firms. ... Read CP26/40 (PDF) ... Why we are consultingIn its current form, the cap limits pension schemes from considering asset classes where performance fees are more…
Extract from FCA . Read the full notice at the source for the authoritative text.